When comparing cruises, it’s typically a toss-up between the most popular commercial cruise lines.
Some may wonder, is Royal Caribbean better than Carnival?
Or is the opposite true?
Speaking practically, deciding which cruise line is “better” can be tricky.
Because, yes; both cruise lines are popular.
But they’re popular for very different reasons.
Royal Caribbean is known for its bigger ships, high-tech entertainment, and premium dining.
Carnival is famous for its affordable prices, lively atmosphere, and casual vibe.
Let’s compare entertainment, food, onboard activities, pricing, and cabins to see which cruise line best fits your style.
Atmosphere: Which Cruise Line Feels Better?
Royal Caribbean Has a More Upscale Feel
Royal Caribbean ships are bigger and – because they’re newer models – feel more modern.
The atmosphere onboard is a mix of luxury, exclusivity, and controlled adventure.
It’s perfect for families and couples who want excitement and premium experiences.
Guests can expect sleek designs, fine dining, and Broadway-style shows.
So in this regard, is Royal Caribbean better than Carnival?
Only if you’d prefer a high-end vacation with lots of activities and attractions.
Carnival Has a More Casual and Social Vibe
Carnival markets itself as a laid-back cruise that’s lively, vibrant, and fun.
Known as the “fun ship” cruise line, it attracts younger travelers, families, and groups looking for a relaxing and affordable getaway.
You can expect poolside parties, live music, and plenty of social events.
In this case, Carnival is better than Royal Caribbean for solo travelers on a budget.
Especially those who prefer a high-energy, low-maintenance sea escapade.
Onboard Activities: Which Cruise Line Has More to Do?
Royal Caribbean Offers High-Tech Attractions
As the more modern of the two, Royal Caribbean has more innovative attractions at sea.
Some highlights include:
- Surf simulators (FlowRider)
- Rock climbing walls
- Skydiving simulators
- Ice skating rinks
- Zip lines and escape rooms
- The Ultimate Abyss aka the tallest slide at sea
If you like thrilling, adrenaline-pumping attractions and modern technology, Royal Caribbean is the better option.
Carnival Focuses on Classic Fun
Carnival offers traditional cruise activities with a focus on socializing and community interaction.
Some of their top onboard attractions include:
- WaterWorks water parks
- Mini-golf and jogging tracks
- Poolside movies and dance parties
- BOLT aka the first roller coaster at sea
If you enjoy a more social, easygoing cruise with group activities, Carnival is a better choice.
Entertainment: Which Cruise Line Has Better Shows?
Royal Caribbean Features Broadway-Style Performances
Is Royal Caribbean better than Carnival when it comes to entertainment?
If you love live theater, big productions, and over-the-top entertainment, then yes; Royal Caribbean delivers.
Some of their top options include:
- Broadway musicals like Mamma Mia! and Grease
- AquaTheater diving and stunt shows
- Ice skating performances by professional skaters
Carnival Focuses on Comedy and Live Music
True to its marketing as a “fun ship,” Carnival Cruises offers live comedy shows and musical performances.
Guests can expect:
- Punchliner Comedy Club with stand-up comedians
- Live music performances in multiple venues
- Interactive game shows and trivia nights
So if you prefer comedy, music, and audience participation over Broadway-style productions, Carnival is definitely the better fit.
Food: Which Cruise Line Has Better Dining?
Carnival Offers More Free Food Options
Carnival is known for great casual dining.
Some of their best free options include:
- Guy’s Burger Joint (created by Guy Fieri)
- Shaq’s Big Chicken
- BlueIguana Cantina (Mexican food)
- 24-hour pizza and soft-serve ice cream
And since most of their food options are included in the cruise price, Carnival is a better choice for budget-conscious travelers.
Royal Caribbean Has More Specialty Dining
Royal Caribbean offers a mix of casual eats and high-end restaurants.
However, its gourmet dining options do cost extra.
Some popular specialty restaurants on Royal Caribbean ships include:
- Chops Grille (steakhouse)
- Izumi Sushi & Teppanyaki
- Jamie’s Italian (by chef Jamie Oliver)
If you don’t mind paying extra for gourmet meals, Royal Caribbean is the better choice.
Royal Caribbean’s buffet and main dining rooms also offer free food that is, admittedly, of a higher quality than Carnival’s.
However, Carnival offers more free options, giving travelers on a budget a more diverse menu.
Pricing: Which Cruise Line is More Affordable?
Carnival is the Lower-Cost Option
Carnival has lower base fares, making it an ideal cruise line for budget travelers.
You can find 3- to 5-night cruises starting under just $300 per person.
And since more food and activities are included in the cruise package, you get great value for your money.
Royal Caribbean Costs More but Offers More
Royal Caribbean’s base prices are definitely higher than Carnival’s.
But their ships are newer, have bigger attractions, and offer high-production entertainment.
Yes, you’ll pay extra for specialty dining and premium experiences, but the overall cruise quality is higher.
So if you prefer quality and don’t mind spending extra, Royal Caribbean is worth its price.
Cabins: Which Cruise Line Has Better Rooms?
Royal Caribbean Has More Unique and Luxury Cabins
Royal Caribbean offers a wider variety of cabins, including:
- Virtual Balcony cabins (interior rooms with digital screens showing ocean views)
- Split-level suites with slides inside
- Luxury suites with private lounge access
When it comes to lodging, is Royal Caribbean better than Carnival?
If you want high-end rooms with modern features, then yes – Royal Caribbean is the better choice.
Carnival Has Bigger Standard Cabins
Carnival’s rooms may not be as modern as Royal Caribbean’s, but they’re much bigger.
Their standard cabins are more spacious and can comfortably fit families of four or five.
They also have Havana and Family Harbor suite options with exclusive lounge access.
So if you’d like a bigger room for the price you pay, Carnival is the top choice.
Which Cruise Line Offers the Best Value?
The value each cruise line offers truly depends on your personal preference.
Carnival is Best for Budget Travelers
For travelers (especially solo travelers) who want the full cruise experience without breaking the bank, here’s why Carnival might be the best choice for you:
- Lower prices
- More free food options
- A casual, fun atmosphere
Royal Caribbean is Best for Premium Experiences
For cruise enthusiasts who prefer an upscale, high-tech cruise experience – and have the budget to purchase premium add-ons – Royal Caribbean is definitely the cruise line for you.
They offer:
- More activities and attractions
- Bigger, high-tech ships
- Better entertainment and dining
Book Your Perfect Cruise with Team Thompson Travel
So, is Royal Caribbean better than Carnival?
The answer truly depends on what you define as “better.”
Passengers who want an affordable trip won’t appreciate how pricey Royal Caribbean is and how potentially limited the free options are.
On the flip side, if you want premium, high-quality amenities, Carnival might not be up to standard.
If you still can’t decide, let Team Thompson Travel help you find your perfect cruise based on your budget and preferences.
We offer expert planning, personalized service, and the best deals—at no extra cost to you.
Contact us today and let’s book your dream cruise!